Saturday, January 23, 2010

New Concept (in Provo at least) for Revitalizing Neighborhoods

Provo City Transfer of Development Rights: Preserving historic neighborhoods through economic incentives for Developers of high density housing in targeted areas.
Provo City has 6 Historic neighborhoods that have deteriorated due to previous zoning standards and their consequences. Old homes were routinely chopped into duplexes, triplexes or worse, turning them into income property instead of cherished owner occupied residential property. Prime example: Knight Mangum house on the corner of 400 East and Center Street. What was once a family mansion is now 12 apartments for married student housing. Unfortunately, as these homes age, their condition deteriorates excessively due to this sort of density, and the lack of “invested” homeowners living in the homes.
In particular, we see this sort of problem in the Joaquin and Maeser neighborhoods. Literally, hundreds of homes which were built as single family homes have become (or are becoming) legal duplexes, with no requirement of owner occupancy. The area has gone from having three schools to one, due to a decline in the number of children and families living in the area. Fewer homeowners in an area where homes range from 60 to 120 years old means a much greater likelihood of blight, higher crime and a larger number of police calls.
The Goal: Treasured family neighborhoods like the “Avenues”, Capitol Hill or the Westminster area in Salt Lake City which have a physical condition that attracts and retains long term residents and successfully preserves the historic character of the homes.
Can we create this in Provo?
Yes: but not with our current tools. Our current tools of revitalization, while effective, have limitations. They can’t enable us to buy historic homes that have been turned into 4-plexes, convert them back into owner occupied property and make the necessary repairs (usually extensive) that would attract new buyers. The costs are too high, and since we have funded most of our revitalization with CDBG funds, we have income and house price limitations in place.
But we can use lessons learned and certain methods of our revitalization efforts in this process. Our Purchase & Rehabilitation Program has been extremely successful at changing the character of troubled property. We buy blighted homes, and through NeighborWorks Provo, we fix structural, system and visual defects, and sell them to owner occupants. However, our funds are limited, and we have to work within fairly strict limits with this program. Squeezing other funds out of the municipal budget right now would be a difficult, if not impossible, task.
So where could we get the money or resources?
We do have another asset which we haven’t put to use yet; it is called Development Rights. In essence, when we zone a particular property, we “impose” a value upon it. If land is zoned to only allow one house for every 10,000 square feet of land, it is likely less valuable to a developer than land which allows one house for every 5,000 square feet of land. In the past, we’ve simply made those determinations by zone changes, and someone (not the city) benefitted economically. Why shouldn’t we put this tool to work for the benefit of our city?
According to the City’s general plan, there is property in Provo where high future density development is planned. North Joaquin and the Transit Oriented Development area quickly come to mind as examples. Neither currently have very specific zoning in place, so perhaps this is an ideal time to consider it.
How could this work?
In essence, we create a plan which allows developers of these high density areas to gain density bonuses for tackling the projects we want to see happen, but can’t afford to do. They purchase and rehabilitate older, larger houses that have been “chopped up” into places a family would love to live. Deed restrictions are placed on the properties which prevent it from once again becoming multi-family or multi-student housing. Owner occupancy could be required for 20 years. If reasonable, an accessory apartment (which always requires owner occupancy in the main unit) could be maintained. The city would be a party to the restrictive covenant language, with a standing right to enforce the deed restrictions. If the home is historic, it would be placed on the Provo Landmarks Registry.
The density bonus could work as follows:
All properties that are in the RC zone (North Joaquin) have a maximum density assigned by current structures. So for our purposes let’s assume a developer has 4 congruent lots with a current density of 12 units for 1 acre of land. The developer’s project wants to put 40 units on that land. To do that, the developer needs 28 density “credits.” To get those credits, the developer accepts purchase/rehabilitation projects which provide that number of credits.


We would likely want to involve a third party, like NeighborWorks Provo in this process, by enabling them to maintain purchase options on various houses within our targeted rehabilitation area. This could prevent artificial inflation, and provide the city with a dedicated, resident guided, method to determine which properties we focus on. Their experience with rehabilitations would be valuable in guiding a sales contract/density bonus for each property that reflects the complexity of the project, and the property’s particular needs for updating and restoration. Another factor would be where the developer’s property is. So let’s look at an example of how this could work.
• NeighborWorks buys an option on a “fix-up” property which fits the goals of the city and its board of directors. Let’s say the property is a house which has been chopped into a triplex.
• NeighborWorks Staff evaluates the house, and draws up plans for turning the house back into a single family home.
• The cost of these improvements is estimated to be 100k.
• Based on estimated value at re-sale and those costs, NeighborWorks assigns a value of 7 density credits to the project.
So what are the real benefits?
• We use a previously unused asset of our city to fund something beneficial to our historic neighborhoods.
• We let market driven forces accomplish 2 things we want: effectively down-zoning “chopped up” historic properties, and creating housing density where we want it.
• We avoid the political battles of a real down-zone or a fight for Amortization.
• These fixed up historic properties will become “crown jewels” in these neighborhoods, attracting long-term residents who will contribute to the quality and stability of the area.
• A higher degree of historic preservation will further push market forces by turning these areas into “neighborhoods of choice.”
What would our City have to invest?
• Staff time, City Council time to create the ordinance.
• A method of administering the ordinance.
• An amount of money from the General Fund or EDI to seed NeighborWorks or RDA involvement in the plan.
Could this be expanded for other use or other areas?
The simple answer is yes. It could be used in other areas where rental property has become too large a percentage of housing stock, or to simply eliminate structures we feel are counter to our goals for the future. My mind is drawn to deteriorating four plexes which dot our neighborhoods…. In essence, if the density reward is sufficient, the task will be accomplished.
How do we use this within our current systems?
Currently, our development process requires a pro-zone and approval by the planning commission and City Council. In essence, we just make this part of our process. City Staff would evaluate the project, and in that process, make a recommendation to the Council about the number of required density credits the project would need. A formula based on location, density desired, and parking ratio would help us make that determination. If a project has some other benefit to the community, the requirement could be reduced. The Council would then make a final determination as part of the Pro-Zone approval. The beauty of this is the flexibility it offers the city government.

47 comments:

amy said...

A clearly thought-out plan. Tell me what I can do? We are thinking we need a bigger house and alot of the bigger homes in our neighborhood have been divided. We have often looked at many of the houses around us wishing we could turn them back into single family dwellings but its simply not cost effective for us as individuals. What can we do to move these ideas forward? Have you considered sending this posting to the paper?

Sariah Hillam said...

I like it as a compromise that could help protect and strengthen the historic neighborhoods.

Ruth Ann said...

I like the idea very much, but what are we going to do with all of the people that will be displaced?

Joaquin Neighborhood Journal said...

@Amy: I went out this am and met 3 homeowners I didn't know. two are actually new in the neighborhood. I'm going to need the vocal support of the neighborhood to keep NeighborWorks Provo involved in this. This is my worry. I need a program, but I want citizen input somewhere.

@Sariah: I totally agree, and feel like this could help us do just that. Avoiding nasty political battles is a good thing.

@Ruth Ann: Those mostly likely to be displaced are married students. Keeping accessory apartments in a the bigger homes would help with that, and would assure that an owner has to be in residence. I keep hoping BYU would step up to the plate with some more married housing--yet they converted 1/2 or more of the apartments they own on North University to singles to replace Deseret Towers. Any ideas--I like easier development standards for married student apartments in terms of parking.

Sally said...

I like the concepts, we (my husband and I) have been talking about creating a Home Owner's association also. It would be for the purpose of doing renovation.

紅包 said...

人生的光榮,不在永不失敗,而在於能夠屢仆屢起。 ..................................................

Morrise Family said...

We're looking for a house in the Joaquin neighborhood. We'd like to buy an apartment conversion and slowly return it to a single family home as our income and family grows. The problem for us is that most of the houses large enough for us to remain long term require commercial financing. There's a lovely Victorian on the market right now that we'd buy in a heartbeat if it qualified for conventional financing.

九份 said...

thank you for you to make me learn more,thank you∩0∩ ........................................

毅力 said...

三分之一的人生,可以決定另外三分之二的人生!!共勉哦! ....................................................

火吟 said...

Drive carefully. It is not only cars that can be recalled by their Maker.............................................

鄭珮瑜 said...

thank you for you to make me learn more,thank you∩0∩ ........................................

曾嘉慧 said...

Well begun is half done.......................................................

香君 said...

本土辣妹貼圖站 辣妹城人網 辣妹貼圖站自拍本土 辣妹貼圖站自拍 跟辣妹做愛短片 美國辣妹短片 性感辣妹圖 辣妹好 辣妹比基尼 日本辣妹寫真集 免費辣妹 巨乳辣妹影片 辣妹裸體影片 辣妹貼影 辣妹脫衣影片 巨乳辣妹脫衣影片 巨乳辣妹裸體影片 巨乳辣妹裸體 辣妹服務 辣妹直播服務 視訊辣妹照片 辣妹有約綜藝野球 辣妹泰正點 辣妹影片網 日本辣妹裸體 天天看辣妹 神算辣妹 辣妹情貼圖 辣妹奶奶 裸體的辣妹 藝術台辣妹有約 辣妹性感 寫真辣妹 無碼辣妹 台灣藝術台的辣妹有約 辣妹色情片 清涼辣妹自拍 辣媽辣妹後 辣妹性感照片 辣妹好色情片 辣妹圖貼區 辣妹裸體寫真 辣妹自拍照 辣妹生活照片 韓國寫真辣妹 絲襪辣妹自拍 辣妹留言版 辣妹色網 裸體辣妹照片 辣妹偷拍影片 美女短片試看av電影 美女的照片 美女爆乳 網路美女的照片 票選2009美女

淑慧 said...

forgive others but not yourself...................................................

雅婷雅婷宛佳 said...

sex性愛85cc性愛紅爺性愛本土美女性愛免費線上性愛電影交友內容同志聊天室ut同志線上看吊帶襪美女圖后工后宮無碼圭賢七年間的愛歌詞圭賢圖片好色貼片區如何延遲射精如何做愛持久如何做愛最爽如何讓女生舒服宅女的幸福生活同志性愛片同志色網站同志色文學交援妹伊莉討論區小說伊莉貼圖區伊莉影片網伊莉論台伊葉情貼片區伊葉情貼圖全國俱樂部0401視訊美女sex女優影音視訊聊天室ut聊天室

品華yur1095is_newson1 said...

85cc片觀看,77美女dvd影片,熊貓貼區,ut網際聊天,一葉情,av,嘟嘟,影音live秀,a片,做愛影片,視訊做愛,美女短片,78論壇,ut聊天,打飛機,a片,免費視訊,免費視訊,成人影院,性愛小說,辣妹視訊,網路交友,捷克論壇,h影片,色咪咪,免費影片85cc,kiss911,後宮,a片,影音視訊聊天,交友,免費聊天,聊天室交友,做愛影片,線上a片,美女影片,免費影片下載,免費聊天室,視訊做愛,美女視訊聊天

韋于倫成 said...

Care killed the cat. take care yourself..........................

志文 said...

友誼能增進快樂,減少痛苦......................................................

怡君 said...

成人+qvod成人無碼片線上看免費成人漫免費成人文成人色圖片正妹牆無碼直播網正妹牆論壇正妹牆牆正妹薔正咩百人斬母子影片永平工商影片永平回收場永平高中做愛影片正妹照片av正妹無名相簿介紹正妹無名分享本土圖貼本土線上短片本土論壇未成年女優未成年者禁止進入未成年情色影片正日報正妹av片正妹小遊戲正妹分享正妹日本正妹自拍圖正妹相簿分享自拍密錄館 情慾自拍 交友聊天找e爵

佩齊 said...

Virtue is a jewel of great price. ............................................................

esthermelvin said...

你不能改變容貌~~但你可以展現笑容............................................................

歐英傑 said...

很精彩的部落格 期待你的繼續加油........................................

RoseH_Huls21365 said...

來給你加油打氣!!!保重!!! .................................................................

育財 said...

^^~~輕輕鬆鬆的逛部落格,多謝有您的分享哦~~~ .................................................................

王婷珊 said...

Pay somebody back in his own coin..................................................................                           

韻枝 said...

Poverty tries friends.....................................................................

志穎志穎 said...

良言一句三冬暖,惡語傷人六月寒。....................................................................

嘉琬嘉琬 said...

成熟,就是有能力適應生活中的模糊。.................................................................

陳智強 said...

人有兩眼一舌,是為了觀察倍於說話的緣故。............................................................

俊淳俊淳 said...

很榮幸能到你的BLOG留言o^~^o..................................................................

JasonBirk佳琪 said...

友誼能增進快樂,減少痛苦............................................................

黃惠雯 said...

吃飽了嗎?~~~還沒下班,好餓哦.................................[/url]...............

姿柯瑩柯dgdd憶曾g智曾 said...

享受你自己的生活,不要與他人相比。............................................................

莊雅和莊雅和莊雅和 said...

快下班囉~來問個安,跟您打聲招呼............................................................

張雅筑張雅筑 said...

連接生與死這兩塊陸地的橋樑是愛…….......................................................

思恬 said...

好久沒有這樣輕鬆享受閱讀的樂趣了~~留個言邀您分享我的快樂~~............................................................

DaniloM_W志竹olff0615 said...

大師手筆﹐果然不凡............................................................

李家黃喬盈榮 said...

人必須心懷希望,才會活的快樂,日子才過得充實,有意義,有朝氣,有信心。.......................................................

思張張亦 said...

感謝分享,將本身的錯誤想法改正了!............................................................

張忠張鴻水玉 said...

睇完之後覺得有d頓悟..感謝大大分享..˙ 3˙............................................................

秀李李迪秀李李迪 said...

「仁慈」二個字,就能讓冬天三個月都溫暖。..................................................

江仁趙雲虹昆 said...

Quality is better than quantity...................................................................

文汝劉文汝劉文汝劉 said...

從人生中拿走友誼,猶如從生活中移走陽光......................................................................

翊翊翊翊張瑜翊翊翊 said...

很棒的分享~留言支持!............................................................

群育航學 said...

路過留言支持~~~..................................................

江仁趙雲虹昆 said...

變天了~~注意身體,別感冒囉!............................................................

said...

It is never too late to learn.......................................................................